Watched three episodes in one go, no filler, it truly lives up to Director Zheng's reputation. Haha, it's so good. Teacher Ding Yong Dai's acting is superb, and Bai Zi's performance is unexpectedly outstanding. Whether it's a period drama or a costume drama, they nailed it. The interactions between the main characters are full of energy. *Updated* The storyline involving the female lead's parents is also very touching. The wedding scene is fantastic!
NewPhD1711 months ago rating:8.4
Director Zheng Xiaolong, screenwriter Gao Mantang, and starring Ding Yong Dai, this era drama depicting the theme of railway public security spanning over 40 years since the reform and opening up is of high quality! From what I've seen so far, the characters are well-developed! The old trains from different periods portrayed in the drama authentically recreate the trains people used to travel on in the past decades. The various dialects spoken by people traveling southbound and northbound, especially the Sichuan dialect's "zei wazi," feel very familiar. Additionally, Bai Jing Ting has shown noticeable improvement in his acting skills in recent years, and I look forward to seeing him make a breakthrough.
Read Moreˇ
ZTS11 months ago rating:6.8
This period drama, featuring veteran actors and being broadcasted on CCTV at the beginning of the year, seems to be a highly anticipated "blockbuster of the year" aiming to follow in the footsteps of "All Is Well on the Train." However, in various aspects, it falls a bit short. The craftsmanship of the screenwriting feels a bit heavy, with traces of being written just for the sake of it. There are several moments in the plot that only lack subtitles saying, "This is the part where you should be moved to tears." In comparison, the literary quality and seamless flow of "All Is Well on the Train" are truly remarkable. The sense of grandeur that makes the river of unpredictable destiny flow, along with the almost effortless performances of all the actors who seem to embody their characters from the moment they appear on screen, is something that is difficult for an average production team to catch up with. In contrast, the two leading actors representing the younger generation in this drama still lack a bit of skill and chemistry, and their on-screen pairing feels forced. Mr. Ding seems to struggle a bit in carrying the weight of the show.
Read Moreˇ
Dorine Gorz10 months ago rating:5.4
Bai Jing Ting's acting skills are lacking, and his Northeastern accent is completely unconvincing. It's basically a joke for him to take on a leading role in a period drama, not to mention his unimpressive appearance. I feel sorry for my beloved teacher, Ding Yong Dai, having to act alongside him throughout the entire drama.
Twilight10 months ago rating:5.7
Bai Jing Ting's acting skills are disappointing. He was decent in previous dramas like "City Siege," but as soon as it comes to a serious production, his true colors show. The premise of this drama was actually good, and it seemed perfect to watch during the Lunar New Year. However, the plot lacks highlights, and the veteran actors are doing their best. In the later episodes, if the drama doesn't catch up, it's just going to be like this. After all, the male lead doesn't lift the drama, and there are more hot searches than actual substance.
HuaErJie11 months ago rating:9.7
It's great! So hilarious! "Catch the drunkard (second tone)!" "You wear glasses and you're still blind!" "From the southbound, northbound, Jiamusi, Hegang, cotton mill, factory, those about to take over the shift, going to the countryside, joining the work team, returning to the city without finding a job, speculating, flipping, those who steal and commit crimes, they're all honest! " "You're not good at being a person, but you're definitely the best at being a thief!" "From a distance, you look like a beggar, up close, you look like a scavenger, but upon closer inspection, you're from the locomotive depot! " "If I can't handle this conversation, I'll drop to the ground. It's so annoying!" Haha, southbound, northbound, are you trying to make me laugh to death????????????
Read Moreˇ
LWikiiin10 months ago rating:6.7
Bai Jing Ting stands out among a group of veteran actors. His Northeastern accent is awkward for me to listen to. It's fine for young actors to work and have fun with their peers, but when facing senior actors, he really can't keep up. Ding Yong Dai and Fang Zi Bin, the respected teachers, are immersed in their roles. It's evident that this drama aims to follow the path of realism in the entertainment industry, but it falls short by a large margin. Why do production companies insist on pairing a group of popular actors with talented ones? There isn't a single popular actor who can deliver a powerful performance. It would be so much better to have a group of good actors who focus on acting sincerely. They would still gain popularity, and the audience would love them just the same. Also, what's going on with the costume and set design in this drama? Both the costumes and scenery are entirely modern. Is this really directed by Zheng Xiaolong?
Read Moreˇ
Knightley11 months ago rating:5.4
The seasoned actor's performance is so genuine and heartfelt. It's like he abruptly "cut and pasted" himself into the role. His unique acting style is refreshing and innovative. In fact, if you've been following his career from the beginning, you'll notice that he tends to "copy and paste" himself into every character. Even off-screen, he meticulously crafts various personas: a socially awkward dance enthusiast on Douyin, a trendy guy on Xiaohongshu, a witty and clever man on Weibo, carefully curating his presence on Douban and Zhihu, a man afraid of strong women when he's single, and a devoted partner when in a relationship. He effortlessly garners a massive following on all platforms, and he has complete control over public opinion. Even when fashion influencers collectively lose their sense of style, he manages to stay in the spotlight. When he wants to trend, even a single comment can make it happen. And he doesn't let his on-screen relationships go idle either. Regardless of the gender, he stirs up a frenzy, causing a massive flood of attention when a new drama is released.
Read Moreˇ
TaintedSky™10 months ago rating:9.6
After the pandemic, we have been seeing exquisite period dramas every year. From "In the World" to "Glory of the Fathers" and now "North and South," each one has a great cast and combines historical events with family stories. We don't need to envy Korean dramas like "Reply 1988" anymore. Stories like these seem to resonate with our country. They are suitable for older generations to watch and the plot reflects the times while showcasing patriotism and a sense of family.
The first episode was already captivating. Ma Kui's mysterious appearance piqued our curiosity, and his reunion with Xiao Wang was filled with comedic effect. The revelation of Old Ma's background was thought-provoking. At first, I thought he might have been a long-time spy or someone who underwent years of labor reform, but the actual revelation was even more dramatic. I'm really looking forward to how the story unfolds.
Having this drama during the winter break means I have a way to spend time with my parents.
Read Moreˇ
FieldGuardian10 months ago rating:5.5
The basic premise is full of loopholes: From 1958 to 1983, individual freedom of migration was largely restricted. The discussion about the one-child policy started gradually in 1979... Who would ride on such a clean and spacious train? As for some people's acting skills that seem like time travel, let's not even comment on that.
AceMandy11 months ago rating:9.6
It's great, it's great! The plot and pacing are really comfortable, and the first episode is captivating. It has humor, warmth, and mystery. The entire cast delivers outstanding performances. The actors portray their roles with authenticity, and there's no letdown in the scenes between Bai Jing Ting and the veteran actors. I particularly love the scenes of master and disciple fighting each other; it's so enjoyable to watch. It's especially suitable for the whole family to watch during the Lunar New Year!
Q10 months ago rating:9.7
A heartwarming and entertaining drama, a drama with conscience. The cast itself makes people irresistibly want to watch. Bai Jing Ting, despite not having a formal acting background, has honed his acting skills and improved greatly. And there are many veteran actors as well. Watching their performances is truly a delight, and it's a drama that I'll sit in front of the TV with my family every day to watch.
ChenEverlasting11 months ago rating:7.3
Tonight on Channel 8, two new dramas. Both Zhou Yi Wei and Bai Jing Ting have a good reputation for their acting and character, so I paid attention to both. Interestingly, they are both detective-themed shows. One involves catching thieves on a train and even includes a Sherlock Holmes reference, while Di Ren Jie is like the "Oriental Sherlock Holmes" with only one person in the "Southern Hemisphere of the Big Dipper." However, it's a pity that there is a lack of depth and weightiness. Many scenes feel like small-scale theatrical performances, lacking authenticity and coming across as empty and superficial. It completely fails to capture the true essence of human experiences, giving off a strong sense of artificiality and leaving an impression of slick-tongued smoothness. The editing lacks a sense of rhythm, and the shows fail to evoke emotions, making it difficult to fully engage with the story.
Read Moreˇ
Syl.10 months ago rating:5.3
Ma, who has been in labor camps for 10 years, why does he constantly attack the younger generation like a firecracker once he's released? He never tires of personal attacks. Although it may be a generational issue, it's excessive... And Niu Da Li's character design is just speechless. The editing is jarring... I can understand that the production team wanted to recreate the nostalgic period drama, but the quality is nowhere near comparable at the moment. Female actors should really have less appearance anxiety; their faces become stiff and can't express emotions when they've had too much work done.
Read Moreˇ
EveningGownMask10 months ago rating:6.7
I watched the first episode seriously. Although it can't be called terrible, it's truly mediocre and tasteless. Teacher Ding Yongdai's acting is still solid, but the performances of others, including the usually skilled at portraying ordinary people, Si Bao Song Jia Teng, and Wang Xun, all show traces of overacting. As for the set design, it's too fake, like a stage play. Just like "The Glory of the Older Generation," there's a giveaway, you can tell it's staged. The train carriage, which is supposed to be crucial, is too clean and lacks that smoky atmosphere. The down-to-earth vibe of Northeast China is also not captured at all.
As for the script, there are deliberate conflicts and suspenseful designs. Especially when Ma Kui appears, why did he run away on the train? Wasn't he released after serving his sentence? How did he become Wang Xin's master so quickly? And he spent ten years in prison... when he came home, he just casually had dinner with his wife and daughter, as if nothing happened. Shouldn't the director have arranged a scene showing the awkwardness and gradual breaking of the ice between him and his wife and daughter after a long separation? Everything feels so abrupt, rushed, without the natural flow and inner dramatic tension that a realistic-themed drama should have. I was genuinely interested in the theme, the conflicts between the North and the South, but the director and the screenwriter rushed it.
Read Moreˇ
Shuoduo10 months ago rating:5.2
There's no sense of liveliness, it feels more like acting inside a makeshift tent. In the morning courtyard scenes, there's no smoke coming out of the chimney. There's a fully blossomed white flower tree, but not a trace on the ground. Everything tells me that these people are just acting. Once again, I can't help but marvel at how unreal the world can be.
IKIN11 months ago rating:6.3
Bai Jing Ting really can't handle this kind of drama. Acting in a historical setting or playing a puppet is passable, but his performance in Northeastern dialect is particularly awkward. Jin Chen's face looks strange, especially her nose. She really shouldn't have had any more cosmetic procedures. Moreover, there's a lack of the nostalgic atmosphere that is characteristic of period dramas. There's nothing appealing about it. Maybe it can still entertain some people, but personally, I can't continue watching this drama. It can't compare to "All Is Well on the Train" and others. I'll give two stars solely for the veteran actors.
Read Moreˇ
SnowScent11 months ago rating:6.8
Thought it was "The Long Season" or "In the World," but it turned out to be a sitcom called "Stories on the Train," and a low-budget version at that. The set and lighting are not as good as "Our Days," and the plot and characters are shallow. Both the male and female leads' acting feels exaggerated, making it really hard to get into.
BAzINGA11 months ago rating:5.9
BAzINGA
The scope is too narrow, reminiscent of the nostalgia of railway descendants for the courtyard life of the last century, and the nostalgia for the old way of life. It was originally thought to be a story about passengers on the train, but it turned out to be a mundane domestic drama about railway descendants. In the constructed railway courtyard, there is neither the history of railway development and changes, nor the striving for a better life that people pursued in that era.
Hahaha10 months ago rating:9.8
This Lunar New Year, with this funny Northeastern dialect, the New Year is surrounding me. Well, watching this drama, even my accent has become influenced. It's a period drama that captures the essence of the era while not lacking in humor and comedy. It's a heartwarming and delightful drama that showcases family bonds, friendships, love, and the camaraderie among neighbors. The most prominent aspect is how it takes place on a train journey, depicting the stories between train police and ordinary people, witnessing the trajectory of railway development and societal changes.
The seemingly trivial matters can escalate into something significant." This line really resonated with me. People emerged from a closed and rigid state after the reform and opening-up, gradually forming a good atmosphere of seeking truth, daring to change, and embracing innovation. Moreover, in this world, there are countless emotions and things. You always have to let go of everything, learn to go with the flow, and be a good person. This drama with a good conscience, in any case, I really appreciate it. It's definitely worthy of five stars!
Read Moreˇ
SweetFruit10 months ago rating:6.3
Dropped the drama around episode 12. It started off really promising, but as it progressed, it became tiresome. It was either about a love triangle in a courtyard or catching thieves on a train, with repetitive jumps and the addition of seemingly funny moments. It felt more like a skit than a TV drama, divided into segments that even if you missed several episodes, you wouldn't have trouble understanding. You could connect the storylines from anywhere, and it's good for mindless entertainment, background noise, or killing time. However, if you sit down to watch it seriously for a long time, you'll feel like you're wasting your time. It's a shame considering the strong cast and the artificial-looking scenes.
Read Moreˇ
Destiny10 months ago rating:8.2
Destiny
Southbound and Northbound" is not only suitable for the whole family to watch during the Spring Festival, but also an extraordinary masterpiece that transcends time and touches the heart. Through delicate character portrayals and plot design, the director allows the audience to gain a deep understanding of the hardships and challenges faced by railway police, while also experiencing the warmth of home and genuine emotions. On this special holiday, let "Southbound and Northbound" bring a special touch and memories to the whole family!
Snowy10 months ago rating:9.6
Journey North and South" is undoubtedly a masterpiece suitable for the whole family to watch during the Spring Festival. The director, with exquisite skills and rich emotional depth, has successfully created a series that combines intense and thrilling plotlines with a warm family atmosphere. Watching this drama during the Spring Festival not only allows us to experience the director's delicate emotions and profound understanding of the era but also helps strengthen bonds and brings joy through shared appreciation among family members.
Forest10 months ago rating:9.6
That university professor is really infuriating to watch. I feel like the writers are satirizing certain media figures, who jump to conclusions based on rumors and make subjective judgments while claiming to uncover the truth. They use the banner of justice to engage in hypocritical actions.
Wanderer10 months ago rating:9.1
What I find truly realistic about this drama is that every character has their good and bad sides. Despite being nosy, they are also caring. Although they enjoy gossip, they are the first ones to help when neighbors are in need. They are genuinely kind, simple, and real people.
ChildhoodMem10 months ago rating:9.6
I really like the character Yao'er. She expresses her feelings openly and confidently when facing her crush. Da Li is actually quite good too. Both of them are pursuing their own love without doing anything wrong, and they are braver than many people.
LonePeak11 months ago rating:7
After watching a couple of episodes, I finally noticed a flaw. In the second episode, during the train's bend, it was clearly a snowy scene, but when they mentioned the thief, the scenery outside the window turned lush green. Also, I don't understand why the protagonist's master keeps undermining him just because his father didn't testify when he witnessed the murder in the past. It feels excessive to keep harping on this point. It's an old generation's matter, what does it have to do with his son's generation? Moreover, the master even personally came to accompany and drink with him, but he rejected it! And that character, Jin Cheng, is really not suitable for him. That role should be played by a much younger actor, someone with more youthfulness, not someone in their thirties like him. The review was right; it's true. Trains from the last century couldn't possibly be cleaner than the high-speed trains of this century, not to mention people still eating sunflower seeds on the train nowadays.
Read Moreˇ
WangYueZhi10 months ago rating:6
As a railway family member, I was initially looking forward to this drama, but it seems to fall short compared to real life. I feel that the male lead couldn't live up to expectations, especially since he doesn't quite look like someone from Northeast China. Why not cast a male actor from the Northeast? Ding Yong Dai and Hu Ke delivered impressive performances, and the guest veteran actors were also excellent. The romantic scenes between the male and female leads in the plot were overly emphasized and felt tiresome. Moreover, the love triangle storyline made the character Ling'er seem shallow and fickle. The young people's story should have been the main highlight. The stories on the train revolving around the train police and passengers were interesting, but I always felt that the male lead was given too much prominence. On the contrary, the stories within the residential compound were more intriguing, and the ensemble cast was more engaging. For example, the Egg King's disappearance plotline was hilarious.
Read Moreˇ
FreedomFreak10 months ago rating:8.3
During the Spring Festival, it's not easy to choose a series that the whole family will enjoy. However, "Coming and Going" is definitely a choice that won't disappoint you. With its excellent plot, stellar performances by the cast, and the director's masterful skills, this work has successfully won the hearts of the audience. It is not just an entertainment piece but also a profound exploration of human nature, family, and emotions. In this joyful moment, let "Coming and Going" bring a rare resonance and reflection for the whole family!
LoneStar10 months ago rating:8.8
Let "Northbound Journey" accompany the whole family through a warm and unforgettable holiday this Spring Festival! The director, through exquisite skills and a penetrating portrayal of emotions, vividly showcases the unique charm and genuine emotions of that era. Whether it's the older generation or the younger generation, they can find resonance and inspiration in this drama. It is not just a drama, but also a memory of time and a transmission of emotions.
Savory10 months ago rating:9.5
The character Yao Yu Ling feels quite authentic. She knows exactly what she wants and there's nothing wrong with being practical. Who says girls can't pursue material things? Does it mean girls should stick with guys who have nothing? In reality, there are many naive girls who end up sacrificing themselves for such relationships. Supporting someone like Yao Yu Ling means at least you won't lack material comforts.
Taro Lover10 months ago rating:9.1
Southbound, Northbound" portrays a realistic and delicate depiction of a captivating story that deeply resonates with the audience. The director's keen insight and outstanding storytelling skills seamlessly blend the challenges of railway public security with family emotions, allowing the audience to reflect and grow while being moved by the narrative.
BeanFriendmMe8A7Jyrg10 months ago rating:9.6
No need to say anything else, straight-up five stars! It has such a nostalgic vibe, such a familiar taste. Anyone who gives it one star must be out of touch! If you don't like it, you don't have to watch it. It's best if you don't watch a single episode. The only thing I hope is that you don't leave shallow and attention-seeking comments!
Blue10 months ago rating:8
Jin Chen's plastic surgery face is so unattractive. With so many talented actors in this great drama, having a face that doesn't fit in is really out of place. In that era, no child would dare to speak to their parents in such a disrespectful tone. People from well-mannered families wouldn't tolerate such behavior from their children.
Amx10 months ago rating:9.9
So far, I really love it. The dialogues in the drama are my favorite part. There's constant banter, unintentional humor, and a continuous flow. People coming and going, crossing paths from the south to the north. In that era, when you meet, you must cherish the time together because the next parting might be the last time you see each other.
Rteekk10 months ago rating:9
At first, I thought it would be a heartwarming family-friendly drama, like a typical courtyard scene. But now, I realize that the screenwriter genuinely wanted to create a slice-of-life drama that portrays the lives of ordinary people. These characters, full of vibrant energy, can truly resonate with the audience.
TimeGuard10 months ago rating:8.3
My friend's dad is a railway detective. Every time it's Chinese New Year, he can never reunite with his family. While others are on their way to reunite, they are the ones safeguarding the journey for others to reunite. This drama is quite meaningful.
HelloXin10 months ago rating:7.3
To be honest, after reading the synopsis on Douban, I found out that it's set in Dalian, which is in Northeast China. I really couldn't tell at all. The female lead's acting is even worse than the male lead's, and the male lead's character is relatively simple, hot-blooded, and impulsive. The female lead had a father who was imprisoned for ten years, a childhood lacking paternal love, and was bullied by peers. The male lead is someone who helped her out when he saw injustice, and his character is relatively complex. But Jin Chen didn't portray any of that. Her longing and resentment towards her father, her inferiority and secret admiration for the male lead, and her care and strength towards her mother and family were completely absent.
Read Moreˇ
Sue10 months ago rating:6.9
It's hard to believe that this is a major drama featuring the combination of Zheng Xiaolong and Gao Mantang. It's so, so dull that it makes me want to fall asleep. I have no idea where the climax is supposed to be. Is it going to be a quadrangle love affair later on?... They say it's a period drama, but the characteristics of that era and some significant events are not portrayed. The most important aspect of a period drama is capturing the changes of the times and the personal destinies. The acting skills of the male and female leads are also quite mediocre. They just don't seem like people from that era.
Read Moreˇ
DawnDusk10 months ago rating:7.7
Previous promotions claimed it to be iQiyi's blockbuster of the year, as if it was the 2.0 version of the real world. Perhaps my expectations were too high. The most interesting aspects of the drama are basically what can be found in short videos online. The other plotlines are somewhat monotonous. Jin Chen's character and the period drama feel a bit disconnected. It feels like she's not part of the same show as her father. King Jiji is the funniest character in the entire drama, and Xiaobai's softened northeastern dialect could be more closely aligned with the character.
Read Moreˇ
Must Smile10 months ago rating:9.9
Director's "Coming and Going" is undoubtedly one of the most suitable series for the whole family to watch during this year's Spring Festival. With its unique perspective and delicate narrative techniques, the director seamlessly blends the perseverance and dedication of railway public security with family emotions, allowing the audience to feel the warmth and power of home amidst laughter and tears. This work is not only a visual feast but also a spiritual baptism, worthy of every family's shared appreciation during the Spring Festival.
Undersea Star10 months ago rating:9.9
The whole family watched "Travelling South and North" together and experienced the hardships and challenges faced by railway police, making this Spring Festival more meaningful. We got to experience the elegance and atmosphere of that era, feel the genuine human emotions, and the director's works always have the power to touch people's hearts, evoking resonance and introspection while watching.
Wanda10 months ago rating:8.8
One highlight of this drama, in my opinion, is that you can't predict the storylines the screenwriter has arranged for each character. Just when you thought Wang Xin and Ma Yan were childhood sweethearts, they surprise you with a bold change of heart when faced with unexpected passion. And just when you thought they were about to become a couple, fate intervenes and Wang Xin is left heartbroken.
hoqq10 months ago rating:9.6
The way Wang Xin feels about Yao is like the romantic fantasy of a teenage boy towards love. The bold pursuit of a passionate and beautiful girl would make anyone's heart skip a beat. But after the initial excitement, how do they sustain the remaining ordinary moments? This little episode makes these two characters more realistic and the storyline more well-rounded.
Nightowl10 months ago rating:9.5
Journey North and South" is a masterpiece that resonates with people and sparks contemplation. It's perfect for the whole family to watch together during the Spring Festival. The director has brought us a profound, heartwarming, and meaningful drama! Let's all experience the charm and genuine emotions of that era during this festive season!
Eraser11 months ago rating:9.8
It makes me angry when I see the human traffickers. They destroy so many families for their own benefit. They have hands and feet, why can't they earn money in a legitimate way? It's infuriating, it's infuriating! (But let me secretly say, the actress who played the human trafficker did an excellent job. I've been watching her dramas since I was young!)
SlimPay11 months ago rating:8.2
As a period drama depicting a collective of emotions, "Southbound and Northbound" not only showcases the glamour of railway public security, but also allows us to experience the unique charm and genuine human emotions of that era through its rich ensemble of characters and emotional storylines. I have to admire the meticulousness of the directors!
Oupp10 months ago rating:9.1
The character Ma Yan was initially quite average. However, since Wang Xin started the parallel storyline, I feel that Ma Yan's character has become really charming. She embodies the typical northeastern woman—casual and carefree on the surface, making you think she doesn't know much, but deep down, she's very aware and clear-minded. She believes that enjoying the present moment is more important than anything else. Every day, she lives happily and joyfully. My mom often says, "Happiness is a day, just like sadness is a day. Why not choose to be happy for a day? " I feel that people like her can provide great comfort and encouragement to those around them. She is truly the most suitable match for Wang Xin.
Read Moreˇ
PeachYogurt10 months ago rating:8.4
The set of the railway courtyard in the drama seems to be artificially constructed. The scenery doesn't feel very natural and it's a bit off.
Hu Ke and Jin Chen playing mother and daughter feels a bit mismatched. They seem to be around the same age. Jin Chen's appearance is particularly modern, more like a trendy beauty from Hong Kong than someone from that era.
Bai Jing Ting and Jiang Yan have better chemistry. I hope the main focus of the drama is not just romance.
I really enjoy watching period dramas. Although I didn't experience that era, I always feel that even though they lacked many things back then, everything was more genuine and the relationships between people were purer.
I'm really tired nowadays.
Read Moreˇ
DoubleComma10 months ago rating:6
It's okay to watch as a comedy film, but the part where the Ma family adopts a child is quite frustrating. Clearly, their own health is not good, yet they insist on adopting and burdening themselves. In the prevailing mindset of the male lead being the breadwinner and the female lead taking care of the household, this child will likely end up being taken care of by their daughter after the female lead's passing, at most with some help from the neighbors. And they talk about how the child can support their older sister when they grow up. Oh my, raising a child alone by the older sister would take at least a decade, the return on investment is too long. It's really hard to believe.
Watched three episodes in one go, no filler, it truly lives up to Director Zheng's reputation. Haha, it's so good. Teacher Ding Yong Dai's acting is superb, and Bai Zi's performance is unexpectedly outstanding.
Whether it's a period drama or a costume drama, they nailed it. The interactions between the main characters are full of energy. *Updated* The storyline involving the female lead's parents is also very touching.
The wedding scene is fantastic!
Director Zheng Xiaolong, screenwriter Gao Mantang, and starring Ding Yong Dai, this era drama depicting the theme of railway public security spanning over 40 years since the reform and opening up is of high quality! From what I've seen so far, the characters are well-developed!
The old trains from different periods portrayed in the drama authentically recreate the trains people used to travel on in the past decades. The various dialects spoken by people traveling southbound and northbound, especially the Sichuan dialect's "zei wazi," feel very familiar.
Additionally, Bai Jing Ting has shown noticeable improvement in his acting skills in recent years, and I look forward to seeing him make a breakthrough.
This period drama, featuring veteran actors and being broadcasted on CCTV at the beginning of the year, seems to be a highly anticipated "blockbuster of the year" aiming to follow in the footsteps of "All Is Well on the Train." However, in various aspects, it falls a bit short.
The craftsmanship of the screenwriting feels a bit heavy, with traces of being written just for the sake of it. There are several moments in the plot that only lack subtitles saying, "This is the part where you should be moved to tears." In comparison, the literary quality and seamless flow of "All Is Well on the Train" are truly remarkable.
The sense of grandeur that makes the river of unpredictable destiny flow, along with the almost effortless performances of all the actors who seem to embody their characters from the moment they appear on screen, is something that is difficult for an average production team to catch up with.
In contrast, the two leading actors representing the younger generation in this drama still lack a bit of skill and chemistry, and their on-screen pairing feels forced. Mr. Ding seems to struggle a bit in carrying the weight of the show.
Bai Jing Ting's acting skills are lacking, and his Northeastern accent is completely unconvincing. It's basically a joke for him to take on a leading role in a period drama, not to mention his unimpressive appearance.
I feel sorry for my beloved teacher, Ding Yong Dai, having to act alongside him throughout the entire drama.
Bai Jing Ting's acting skills are disappointing. He was decent in previous dramas like "City Siege," but as soon as it comes to a serious production, his true colors show.
The premise of this drama was actually good, and it seemed perfect to watch during the Lunar New Year. However, the plot lacks highlights, and the veteran actors are doing their best.
In the later episodes, if the drama doesn't catch up, it's just going to be like this. After all, the male lead doesn't lift the drama, and there are more hot searches than actual substance.
It's great! So hilarious! "Catch the drunkard (second tone)!" "You wear glasses and you're still blind!" "From the southbound, northbound, Jiamusi, Hegang, cotton mill, factory, those about to take over the shift, going to the countryside, joining the work team, returning to the city without finding a job, speculating, flipping, those who steal and commit crimes, they're all honest!
" "You're not good at being a person, but you're definitely the best at being a thief!" "From a distance, you look like a beggar, up close, you look like a scavenger, but upon closer inspection, you're from the locomotive depot!
" "If I can't handle this conversation, I'll drop to the ground. It's so annoying!" Haha, southbound, northbound, are you trying to make me laugh to death????????????
Bai Jing Ting stands out among a group of veteran actors. His Northeastern accent is awkward for me to listen to. It's fine for young actors to work and have fun with their peers, but when facing senior actors, he really can't keep up.
Ding Yong Dai and Fang Zi Bin, the respected teachers, are immersed in their roles. It's evident that this drama aims to follow the path of realism in the entertainment industry, but it falls short by a large margin.
Why do production companies insist on pairing a group of popular actors with talented ones? There isn't a single popular actor who can deliver a powerful performance. It would be so much better to have a group of good actors who focus on acting sincerely.
They would still gain popularity, and the audience would love them just the same. Also, what's going on with the costume and set design in this drama? Both the costumes and scenery are entirely modern.
Is this really directed by Zheng Xiaolong?
The seasoned actor's performance is so genuine and heartfelt. It's like he abruptly "cut and pasted" himself into the role. His unique acting style is refreshing and innovative. In fact, if you've been following his career from the beginning, you'll notice that he tends to "copy and paste" himself into every character.
Even off-screen, he meticulously crafts various personas: a socially awkward dance enthusiast on Douyin, a trendy guy on Xiaohongshu, a witty and clever man on Weibo, carefully curating his presence on Douban and Zhihu, a man afraid of strong women when he's single, and a devoted partner when in a relationship.
He effortlessly garners a massive following on all platforms, and he has complete control over public opinion. Even when fashion influencers collectively lose their sense of style, he manages to stay in the spotlight.
When he wants to trend, even a single comment can make it happen. And he doesn't let his on-screen relationships go idle either. Regardless of the gender, he stirs up a frenzy, causing a massive flood of attention when a new drama is released.
After the pandemic, we have been seeing exquisite period dramas every year. From "In the World" to "Glory of the Fathers" and now "North and South," each one has a great cast and combines historical events with family stories.
We don't need to envy Korean dramas like "Reply 1988" anymore. Stories like these seem to resonate with our country. They are suitable for older generations to watch and the plot reflects the times while showcasing patriotism and a sense of family.
The first episode was already captivating. Ma Kui's mysterious appearance piqued our curiosity, and his reunion with Xiao Wang was filled with comedic effect. The revelation of Old Ma's background was thought-provoking.
At first, I thought he might have been a long-time spy or someone who underwent years of labor reform, but the actual revelation was even more dramatic. I'm really looking forward to how the story unfolds.
Having this drama during the winter break means I have a way to spend time with my parents.
The basic premise is full of loopholes: From 1958 to 1983, individual freedom of migration was largely restricted. The discussion about the one-child policy started gradually in 1979...
Who would ride on such a clean and spacious train? As for some people's acting skills that seem like time travel, let's not even comment on that.
It's great, it's great! The plot and pacing are really comfortable, and the first episode is captivating. It has humor, warmth, and mystery. The entire cast delivers outstanding performances. The actors portray their roles with authenticity, and there's no letdown in the scenes between Bai Jing Ting and the veteran actors.
I particularly love the scenes of master and disciple fighting each other; it's so enjoyable to watch. It's especially suitable for the whole family to watch during the Lunar New Year!
A heartwarming and entertaining drama, a drama with conscience. The cast itself makes people irresistibly want to watch. Bai Jing Ting, despite not having a formal acting background, has honed his acting skills and improved greatly.
And there are many veteran actors as well. Watching their performances is truly a delight, and it's a drama that I'll sit in front of the TV with my family every day to watch.
Tonight on Channel 8, two new dramas. Both Zhou Yi Wei and Bai Jing Ting have a good reputation for their acting and character, so I paid attention to both. Interestingly, they are both detective-themed shows.
One involves catching thieves on a train and even includes a Sherlock Holmes reference, while Di Ren Jie is like the "Oriental Sherlock Holmes" with only one person in the "Southern Hemisphere of the Big Dipper." However, it's a pity that there is a lack of depth and weightiness.
Many scenes feel like small-scale theatrical performances, lacking authenticity and coming across as empty and superficial. It completely fails to capture the true essence of human experiences, giving off a strong sense of artificiality and leaving an impression of slick-tongued smoothness.
The editing lacks a sense of rhythm, and the shows fail to evoke emotions, making it difficult to fully engage with the story.
Ma, who has been in labor camps for 10 years, why does he constantly attack the younger generation like a firecracker once he's released? He never tires of personal attacks.
Although it may be a generational issue, it's excessive... And Niu Da Li's character design is just speechless. The editing is jarring... I can understand that the production team wanted to recreate the nostalgic period drama, but the quality is nowhere near comparable at the moment.
Female actors should really have less appearance anxiety; their faces become stiff and can't express emotions when they've had too much work done.
I watched the first episode seriously. Although it can't be called terrible, it's truly mediocre and tasteless. Teacher Ding Yongdai's acting is still solid, but the performances of others, including the usually skilled at portraying ordinary people, Si Bao Song Jia Teng, and Wang Xun, all show traces of overacting.
As for the set design, it's too fake, like a stage play. Just like "The Glory of the Older Generation," there's a giveaway, you can tell it's staged. The train carriage, which is supposed to be crucial, is too clean and lacks that smoky atmosphere.
The down-to-earth vibe of Northeast China is also not captured at all.
As for the script, there are deliberate conflicts and suspenseful designs. Especially when Ma Kui appears, why did he run away on the train?
Wasn't he released after serving his sentence? How did he become Wang Xin's master so quickly? And he spent ten years in prison... when he came home, he just casually had dinner with his wife and daughter, as if nothing happened.
Shouldn't the director have arranged a scene showing the awkwardness and gradual breaking of the ice between him and his wife and daughter after a long separation? Everything feels so abrupt, rushed, without the natural flow and inner dramatic tension that a realistic-themed drama should have.
I was genuinely interested in the theme, the conflicts between the North and the South, but the director and the screenwriter rushed it.
There's no sense of liveliness, it feels more like acting inside a makeshift tent. In the morning courtyard scenes, there's no smoke coming out of the chimney. There's a fully blossomed white flower tree, but not a trace on the ground.
Everything tells me that these people are just acting. Once again, I can't help but marvel at how unreal the world can be.
Bai Jing Ting really can't handle this kind of drama. Acting in a historical setting or playing a puppet is passable, but his performance in Northeastern dialect is particularly awkward. Jin Chen's face looks strange, especially her nose.
She really shouldn't have had any more cosmetic procedures. Moreover, there's a lack of the nostalgic atmosphere that is characteristic of period dramas. There's nothing appealing about it.
Maybe it can still entertain some people, but personally, I can't continue watching this drama. It can't compare to "All Is Well on the Train" and others. I'll give two stars solely for the veteran actors.
Thought it was "The Long Season" or "In the World," but it turned out to be a sitcom called "Stories on the Train," and a low-budget version at that. The set and lighting are not as good as "Our Days," and the plot and characters are shallow.
Both the male and female leads' acting feels exaggerated, making it really hard to get into.
BAzINGA
The scope is too narrow, reminiscent of the nostalgia of railway descendants for the courtyard life of the last century, and the nostalgia for the old way of life.
It was originally thought to be a story about passengers on the train, but it turned out to be a mundane domestic drama about railway descendants. In the constructed railway courtyard, there is neither the history of railway development and changes, nor the striving for a better life that people pursued in that era.
This Lunar New Year, with this funny Northeastern dialect, the New Year is surrounding me. Well, watching this drama, even my accent has become influenced. It's a period drama that captures the essence of the era while not lacking in humor and comedy.
It's a heartwarming and delightful drama that showcases family bonds, friendships, love, and the camaraderie among neighbors. The most prominent aspect is how it takes place on a train journey, depicting the stories between train police and ordinary people, witnessing the trajectory of railway development and societal changes.
The seemingly trivial matters can escalate into something significant." This line really resonated with me. People emerged from a closed and rigid state after the reform and opening-up, gradually forming a good atmosphere of seeking truth, daring to change, and embracing innovation.
Moreover, in this world, there are countless emotions and things. You always have to let go of everything, learn to go with the flow, and be a good person. This drama with a good conscience, in any case, I really appreciate it.
It's definitely worthy of five stars!
Dropped the drama around episode 12. It started off really promising, but as it progressed, it became tiresome. It was either about a love triangle in a courtyard or catching thieves on a train, with repetitive jumps and the addition of seemingly funny moments.
It felt more like a skit than a TV drama, divided into segments that even if you missed several episodes, you wouldn't have trouble understanding. You could connect the storylines from anywhere, and it's good for mindless entertainment, background noise, or killing time.
However, if you sit down to watch it seriously for a long time, you'll feel like you're wasting your time. It's a shame considering the strong cast and the artificial-looking scenes.
Destiny
Southbound and Northbound" is not only suitable for the whole family to watch during the Spring Festival, but also an extraordinary masterpiece that transcends time and touches the heart. Through delicate character portrayals and plot design, the director allows the audience to gain a deep understanding of the hardships and challenges faced by railway police, while also experiencing the warmth of home and genuine emotions.
On this special holiday, let "Southbound and Northbound" bring a special touch and memories to the whole family!
Journey North and South" is undoubtedly a masterpiece suitable for the whole family to watch during the Spring Festival. The director, with exquisite skills and rich emotional depth, has successfully created a series that combines intense and thrilling plotlines with a warm family atmosphere.
Watching this drama during the Spring Festival not only allows us to experience the director's delicate emotions and profound understanding of the era but also helps strengthen bonds and brings joy through shared appreciation among family members.
That university professor is really infuriating to watch. I feel like the writers are satirizing certain media figures, who jump to conclusions based on rumors and make subjective judgments while claiming to uncover the truth.
They use the banner of justice to engage in hypocritical actions.
What I find truly realistic about this drama is that every character has their good and bad sides. Despite being nosy, they are also caring. Although they enjoy gossip, they are the first ones to help when neighbors are in need. They are genuinely kind, simple, and real people.
I really like the character Yao'er. She expresses her feelings openly and confidently when facing her crush. Da Li is actually quite good too. Both of them are pursuing their own love without doing anything wrong, and they are braver than many people.
After watching a couple of episodes, I finally noticed a flaw. In the second episode, during the train's bend, it was clearly a snowy scene, but when they mentioned the thief, the scenery outside the window turned lush green.
Also, I don't understand why the protagonist's master keeps undermining him just because his father didn't testify when he witnessed the murder in the past. It feels excessive to keep harping on this point.
It's an old generation's matter, what does it have to do with his son's generation? Moreover, the master even personally came to accompany and drink with him, but he rejected it! And that character, Jin Cheng, is really not suitable for him.
That role should be played by a much younger actor, someone with more youthfulness, not someone in their thirties like him. The review was right; it's true. Trains from the last century couldn't possibly be cleaner than the high-speed trains of this century, not to mention people still eating sunflower seeds on the train nowadays.
As a railway family member, I was initially looking forward to this drama, but it seems to fall short compared to real life. I feel that the male lead couldn't live up to expectations, especially since he doesn't quite look like someone from Northeast China.
Why not cast a male actor from the Northeast? Ding Yong Dai and Hu Ke delivered impressive performances, and the guest veteran actors were also excellent. The romantic scenes between the male and female leads in the plot were overly emphasized and felt tiresome.
Moreover, the love triangle storyline made the character Ling'er seem shallow and fickle. The young people's story should have been the main highlight. The stories on the train revolving around the train police and passengers were interesting, but I always felt that the male lead was given too much prominence.
On the contrary, the stories within the residential compound were more intriguing, and the ensemble cast was more engaging. For example, the Egg King's disappearance plotline was hilarious.
During the Spring Festival, it's not easy to choose a series that the whole family will enjoy. However, "Coming and Going" is definitely a choice that won't disappoint you. With its excellent plot, stellar performances by the cast, and the director's masterful skills, this work has successfully won the hearts of the audience.
It is not just an entertainment piece but also a profound exploration of human nature, family, and emotions. In this joyful moment, let "Coming and Going" bring a rare resonance and reflection for the whole family!
Let "Northbound Journey" accompany the whole family through a warm and unforgettable holiday this Spring Festival! The director, through exquisite skills and a penetrating portrayal of emotions, vividly showcases the unique charm and genuine emotions of that era.
Whether it's the older generation or the younger generation, they can find resonance and inspiration in this drama. It is not just a drama, but also a memory of time and a transmission of emotions.
The character Yao Yu Ling feels quite authentic. She knows exactly what she wants and there's nothing wrong with being practical. Who says girls can't pursue material things?
Does it mean girls should stick with guys who have nothing? In reality, there are many naive girls who end up sacrificing themselves for such relationships. Supporting someone like Yao Yu Ling means at least you won't lack material comforts.
Southbound, Northbound" portrays a realistic and delicate depiction of a captivating story that deeply resonates with the audience. The director's keen insight and outstanding storytelling skills seamlessly blend the challenges of railway public security with family emotions, allowing the audience to reflect and grow while being moved by the narrative.
No need to say anything else, straight-up five stars! It has such a nostalgic vibe, such a familiar taste. Anyone who gives it one star must be out of touch! If you don't like it, you don't have to watch it. It's best if you don't watch a single episode.
The only thing I hope is that you don't leave shallow and attention-seeking comments!
Jin Chen's plastic surgery face is so unattractive. With so many talented actors in this great drama, having a face that doesn't fit in is really out of place. In that era, no child would dare to speak to their parents in such a disrespectful tone.
People from well-mannered families wouldn't tolerate such behavior from their children.
So far, I really love it. The dialogues in the drama are my favorite part. There's constant banter, unintentional humor, and a continuous flow. People coming and going, crossing paths from the south to the north. In that era, when you meet, you must cherish the time together because the next parting might be the last time you see each other.
At first, I thought it would be a heartwarming family-friendly drama, like a typical courtyard scene. But now, I realize that the screenwriter genuinely wanted to create a slice-of-life drama that portrays the lives of ordinary people.
These characters, full of vibrant energy, can truly resonate with the audience.
My friend's dad is a railway detective. Every time it's Chinese New Year, he can never reunite with his family. While others are on their way to reunite, they are the ones safeguarding the journey for others to reunite.
This drama is quite meaningful.
To be honest, after reading the synopsis on Douban, I found out that it's set in Dalian, which is in Northeast China. I really couldn't tell at all. The female lead's acting is even worse than the male lead's, and the male lead's character is relatively simple, hot-blooded, and impulsive.
The female lead had a father who was imprisoned for ten years, a childhood lacking paternal love, and was bullied by peers. The male lead is someone who helped her out when he saw injustice, and his character is relatively complex. But Jin Chen didn't portray any of that.
Her longing and resentment towards her father, her inferiority and secret admiration for the male lead, and her care and strength towards her mother and family were completely absent.
It's hard to believe that this is a major drama featuring the combination of Zheng Xiaolong and Gao Mantang. It's so, so dull that it makes me want to fall asleep. I have no idea where the climax is supposed to be.
Is it going to be a quadrangle love affair later on?... They say it's a period drama, but the characteristics of that era and some significant events are not portrayed. The most important aspect of a period drama is capturing the changes of the times and the personal destinies.
The acting skills of the male and female leads are also quite mediocre. They just don't seem like people from that era.
Previous promotions claimed it to be iQiyi's blockbuster of the year, as if it was the 2.0 version of the real world. Perhaps my expectations were too high. The most interesting aspects of the drama are basically what can be found in short videos online.
The other plotlines are somewhat monotonous. Jin Chen's character and the period drama feel a bit disconnected. It feels like she's not part of the same show as her father. King Jiji is the funniest character in the entire drama, and Xiaobai's softened northeastern dialect could be more closely aligned with the character.
Director's "Coming and Going" is undoubtedly one of the most suitable series for the whole family to watch during this year's Spring Festival. With its unique perspective and delicate narrative techniques, the director seamlessly blends the perseverance and dedication of railway public security with family emotions, allowing the audience to feel the warmth and power of home amidst laughter and tears.
This work is not only a visual feast but also a spiritual baptism, worthy of every family's shared appreciation during the Spring Festival.
The whole family watched "Travelling South and North" together and experienced the hardships and challenges faced by railway police, making this Spring Festival more meaningful. We got to experience the elegance and atmosphere of that era, feel the genuine human emotions, and the director's works always have the power to touch people's hearts, evoking resonance and introspection while watching.
One highlight of this drama, in my opinion, is that you can't predict the storylines the screenwriter has arranged for each character. Just when you thought Wang Xin and Ma Yan were childhood sweethearts, they surprise you with a bold change of heart when faced with unexpected passion.
And just when you thought they were about to become a couple, fate intervenes and Wang Xin is left heartbroken.
The way Wang Xin feels about Yao is like the romantic fantasy of a teenage boy towards love. The bold pursuit of a passionate and beautiful girl would make anyone's heart skip a beat.
But after the initial excitement, how do they sustain the remaining ordinary moments? This little episode makes these two characters more realistic and the storyline more well-rounded.
Journey North and South" is a masterpiece that resonates with people and sparks contemplation. It's perfect for the whole family to watch together during the Spring Festival. The director has brought us a profound, heartwarming, and meaningful drama!
Let's all experience the charm and genuine emotions of that era during this festive season!
It makes me angry when I see the human traffickers. They destroy so many families for their own benefit. They have hands and feet, why can't they earn money in a legitimate way? It's infuriating, it's infuriating! (But let me secretly say, the actress who played the human trafficker did an excellent job.
I've been watching her dramas since I was young!)
As a period drama depicting a collective of emotions, "Southbound and Northbound" not only showcases the glamour of railway public security, but also allows us to experience the unique charm and genuine human emotions of that era through its rich ensemble of characters and emotional storylines.
I have to admire the meticulousness of the directors!
The character Ma Yan was initially quite average. However, since Wang Xin started the parallel storyline, I feel that Ma Yan's character has become really charming. She embodies the typical northeastern woman—casual and carefree on the surface, making you think she doesn't know much, but deep down, she's very aware and clear-minded.
She believes that enjoying the present moment is more important than anything else. Every day, she lives happily and joyfully. My mom often says, "Happiness is a day, just like sadness is a day. Why not choose to be happy for a day?
" I feel that people like her can provide great comfort and encouragement to those around them. She is truly the most suitable match for Wang Xin.
The set of the railway courtyard in the drama seems to be artificially constructed. The scenery doesn't feel very natural and it's a bit off.
Hu Ke and Jin Chen playing mother and daughter feels a bit mismatched.
They seem to be around the same age. Jin Chen's appearance is particularly modern, more like a trendy beauty from Hong Kong than someone from that era.
Bai Jing Ting and Jiang Yan have better chemistry.
I hope the main focus of the drama is not just romance.
I really enjoy watching period dramas. Although I didn't experience that era, I always feel that even though they lacked many things back then, everything was more genuine and the relationships between people were purer.
I'm really tired nowadays.
It's okay to watch as a comedy film, but the part where the Ma family adopts a child is quite frustrating. Clearly, their own health is not good, yet they insist on adopting and burdening themselves.
In the prevailing mindset of the male lead being the breadwinner and the female lead taking care of the household, this child will likely end up being taken care of by their daughter after the female lead's passing, at most with some help from the neighbors.
And they talk about how the child can support their older sister when they grow up. Oh my, raising a child alone by the older sister would take at least a decade, the return on investment is too long.
It's really hard to believe.