Zhang Yi's acting is excellent. I particularly liked a scene at the end. Finally, he can say goodbye to the past and start a new life. While watching the movie, I always hoped that Bingge could move forward. Fortunately, the director portrayed it, otherwise it would have been really heart-wrenching~
ZhaoBai1 year ago rating:9.8
Looking back at the domestic films I've seen this year, this one should easily rank among the top three. The plot is tightly woven, and the lead actor's performance goes without saying. What impressed me the most throughout the entire film were the cinematography and the music. It's evident that the director put a lot of effort into them. Zhang Yi is truly perfect for this role; it feels like he's the same kind of person in real life. China has finally been able to produce this kind of suspenseful film, and it's something that we can all be proud of.
Bunny1 year ago rating:9.5
I've watched Zhang Yi play a police officer so many times, but I never get tired of it. Instead, it's easy for me to be drawn into the movie. If I like this film, I will also enjoy Liu Huan's ending song. "Ren Jian Dao" depicts Cheng Bing's entire life: "I want to live this life to see the snow orchids. I want to wear out these shoes, barefoot in the windswept desert. I want to witness the clouds and rainbows in the broad sky, and hold a torch at night. I want everything in this vast universe to have its laws. I want those who leave home, no matter how late, to return. I want the rain that falls from the sky to return to the sky. I want to eat this mouthful of rice and guard this wild land. I want all the paths in this world to exist under the blue sky. For a breath, for a principle, for a sacrifice, I will carry on till the end." Cheng Bing truly carries on till the end. There's a scene where Cheng Bing swims across the river to the other side. Cai Bin shouts behind him, urging him to let go. Before this scene, Cai Bin always mentioned the "attachment" in Buddhism. This scene is absolutely amazing. Cheng Bing alone swims to the other side of the river, and he also persists to the end on his own. It's both an attachment and a crossing. I think I will watch the drama version, although I'm a bit scared...
Read Moreˇ
Little Daisy1 year ago rating:5.5
The movie was so disappointing. It's far worse than the TV drama that I'm currently following, which has been touching and made me shed tears uncontrollably. I came to watch the movie with high hopes, but it didn't feel like a movie at all. It was more like a narrative-less PowerPoint presentation. Every plot twist felt forced, without any buildup or logical coherence. Sitting through over two hours of it was agonizing, and it didn't move me at all. I just wanted it to end quickly so I could move on. I don't understand who those people giving it positive reviews are.
Read Moreˇ
GrievingWidow1 year ago rating:8.7
The drama made me sob uncontrollably. It's undoubtedly the best drama of 2023, despite some plot holes that can be overlooked. I deduct one star because of Li Chen's performance (originally wanted to give the movie one star just because of him, but the movie is actually quite good, so it doesn't deserve such low rating).
Adding to that, the plot that I couldn't stand the most is Zhang Yi's family's sudden emotional coldness. Before the incident, it seemed like they wanted to have a third child, but after the incident, it feels like he's the one who killed his wife, lover, and daughter. It's incredibly unsettling.
Read Moreˇ
Levana1 year ago rating:5.4
Is this a new genre of film? A TV drama-style movie? The whole thing feels like a messy mishmash of scenes, and there's always some inexplicable burden that keeps shaking. It lacks rhythm and cinematic quality. I'm sorry, I didn't pay enough attention to the poster, and I completely regret watching it. Chen Sicheng and anyone associated with this project should be avoided in the future.
TragicTale1 year ago rating:6.7
Well, how should I put it? It's a tragic story. However, the middle part is quite lengthy, and I got tired of seeing them chase all over the country. The sudden change in attitude of the few remaining people at Old Zhang's grave felt too abrupt and not as touching as expected.
Zhang Yi's performance feels somewhat formulaic, and his constant gloomy expression throughout the film made it a bit boring to watch.
IcedLatte1 year ago rating:6.1
It seems like Cheng's character is destined for misfortune... Not a single storyline was well executed, and the creators should apologize to the families of the victims. Cheng's character was portrayed by Zhang Yi without any charm. He started off strong, but later on, he should have been more burdened and complex, expressing regret, guilt, and a sense of depth. Almost all the characters were superficially developed and lacked depth. The details were scarce. The editing was poor, and the pacing was off. The balance between elaboration and conciseness was not well-handled. It had a strong masculine vibe, and there were no female characters, none at all.
Read Moreˇ
Arkham761 year ago rating:9.5
At the end of the year, another member joins the list of the top 10 annual domestic releases! This year, there have been many films with a realistic theme, but only "Triple Squad" has delivered a satisfying answer under strict censorship. Despite the use of many effective but clichéd plot elements, the film maintains a smooth pace with its straightforward narrative. It evokes laughter and tears, accompanied by the clues of "chasing the murderer," presenting a comprehensive portrayal of the police officers' dedication to justice. The chef's glance back at the train station ticket gate, the insurance seller's shout amidst the New Year fireworks, and Binzi's cry by the riverbank all depict the struggle for life and ideals. Cheng Bing, who has nothing to lose and nothing to worry about, persists until the end with the belief of the "Triple Squad," leaving behind a lonely yet immensely heroic figure that dissipates into the vast sea of people.
Read Moreˇ
MaplePhoenix1 year ago rating:8.9
I watched this film on a whim, and it started off really well. The cinematography had a nice touch from the very beginning, and it had a gradually building filmic quality. The middle part was fairly tight, but the tension seemed slightly lacking towards the end. And when I saw the faces of the actors playing the Second Brave, I couldn't help but feel a bit strained... (Never expected that!)
The most unexpectedly imaginative episode - Flipping the Door.
Enigma1 year ago rating:9.6
A few years ago, I watched the first part of "Deep Blue Story," but I can't quite remember the original plot. I recall that there were no teammates in the impression. The film's addition of teammates joining and leaving, as well as the master acknowledging his own inability to keep up, is a great adaptation. It adds some interesting plot elements, creates a thrilling and fluctuating pace, and emphasizes Brother Bing's unwavering determination.
The beginning of the film had a feeling similar to a typical detective movie, giving me a sense that it would be very popcorn-worthy. Then, the combination of violin and a big title immediately changed that atmosphere and made it more intriguing. The segment from imprisonment to tomb sweeping temporarily lost the direction of the story, but it necessary to show everyone's changes. The teammates' retirement and the soulful greeting in the ending created a desolate atmosphere.
The conversation with the bureau chief seemed to subtly satirize certain things. The indoor set design was very well done, resembling an ordinary person's home.
The music was stunning! The violin near the music sheet and the lightly distorted electric guitar were used to enhance the tense and ethereal atmosphere, and it was very concise and effective.
The only minor drawback was that the font used when switching cities felt a bit "unrefined" or out of place.
Read Moreˇ
Chandler Han1 year ago rating:9.2
There were several climactic moments in the drama that didn't rely on background music to create impact, showcasing the actors' superb and moving performances. For example, the scene where the male lead, just released from prison, is given tea eggs by his family. Another example is the segment where the team members awaken in the cemetery and go together to apprehend Wang Eryong, which was accompanied by a simple guitar melody to evoke emotions.
JoyfulNut1 year ago rating:8.8
The pursuit of justice as an ordinary person is incredibly long and arduous. In the end, it's all about human matters—being washed by fate and experiencing the brilliance of life. Holding onto one's convictions is not a derogatory term; it means doing what one believes is right and unraveling the knots in one's heart is a lifelong lesson. The tragedy and glimmer of ordinary people serve as a constant reminder.
AhChill~1 year ago rating:6.8
The final thought of the film is, after spending most of one's life in pursuit of a goal, how should the days ahead be lived? Cheng Bing has stayed in the past, but the gears of time don't wait for anyone, and Li Chen's portrayal of Yang Shutao becoming the director is the perfect contrast.
Coco1 year ago rating:6.7
The story is a good one. As soon as I left the cinema, I said to myself, "If this were a novel, it would definitely be very enjoyable to read." Unfortunately, the director failed to showcase the brilliance of the story. The portrayal of the characters felt too artificial and forced, lacking authenticity and naturalness.
Troublemaker1 year ago rating:8.5
It's a good story, and the director's filming techniques are quite impressive. There's a lot of restraint in many aspects. Moreover, the writer starting from the perspective of the male lead is excellent. The years-long pursuit of the culprit, the feelings of resentment, sadness, and injustice are what touch us, the audience, and make us admire those who can persevere. From the first supporter to the first one to leave, to several people leaving due to various real-life issues, we can understand them, but it still feels very painful.
It also reminds me of the earlier work, with Zhang Yi playing the lead role. It's quite ridiculous how the starting perspective is the protagonist on the surface, but actually highlights the difficulty of portraying the antagonist, their deep emotions and sense of loyalty. They deliberately imitate the image of a big brother from Hong Kong films, overlooking the genuine need to tell the story of the righteous side and their internal struggles. The contrast between these two works is significant.
Read Moreˇ
Lin1 year ago rating:9.9
Lao Ma leaving signifies Cheng Bing letting go of his attachment to his wife. Lao Liao leaving signifies Cheng Bing letting go of his longing for his child. Xiao Xu leaving signifies Cheng Bing letting go of a stable life. Bin Zi leaving signifies Cheng Bing letting go of the possibility of redemption. However, leaving does not necessarily mean giving up. Everyone has their own choices. Never ridicule those who are braver and more resilient than oneself.
WhiteChocoWasabi1 year ago rating:9.5
The dark shadow at the alley entrance represents the obsession I chased after, the group photo at the celebration embodies the curse I endured, the graffiti behind the mirror symbolizes the life I gambled on, and the shoe covers at the doorstep signify the fate I exchanged. Neglecting to install burglar-proof windows, my identity was stolen by wicked thieves. Neglecting to purchase life insurance, I played hide-and-seek with destiny. Changing from a uniform to a prisoner's outfit, justice has been frozen in the freezer of the judiciary. The police anthem has turned into prison regulations, and the killer has been reveling in the blocks of a game, evading capture. People come and go, each with their own shore to swim towards.
Read Moreˇ
ShaBaoBao1 year ago rating:9.8
Several police officers went from being full of spirit to being down and out, and it really saddened me from the bottom of my heart. ???? By the end, it felt like Wang Eryong truly had the chance to start anew, just as Lao Liao said: a happy and harmonious family, and he even managed to make himself look respectable despite his past wrongdoings... But why does he get to start over? Can Cheng Bing start over and return to the way things were? Can the other members of the Three Teams, who had promising futures, start over and go back to the past? Everyone can start over, except for Wang Eryong!
Read Moreˇ
IdleTwelve1 year ago rating:8.8
I'm already tired of seeing Zhang Yi in these kinds of roles, but I couldn't resist watching because of Wei Chen's face. How can someone look so handsome with that hairstyle? It's like he was born to be an actor. Oh my goodness!
It's just average, I would recommend it if you simply enjoy watching crime dramas, but I think you might be a bit disappointed with this one. Overall, it feels like it's only focusing on the main character's journey, and the other characters are just carried by the actors' performances.
There seems to be a lot of attention to detail in the design, but it comes across as too straightforward and a bit dry. It's hard to evaluate. I give up, Wei Chen is really handsome, I can't believe it.
Read Moreˇ
erma1 year ago rating:8.8
The pre-internet era of criminal investigations has become the focus of domestic crime film creators. Due to the lack of technological means like surveillance, the process of solving cases is filled with twists and turns. "The Third Squad" achieves a remarkably high level of completion. By employing a more realistic approach and toning down the suspenseful atmosphere, the drama captivates viewers with solid storytelling and compelling performances. Ensembles are the most challenging to write and portray, and although the film mainly focuses on Cheng Bing, portrayed by Zhang Yi, the other characters in "The Third Squad" are equally outstanding. Whether it's the performances of Zhang Zixian, Wang Xiao, Wei Chen, or the detailed characterization of their roles, everything feels authentic and emotionally moving. However, as the story eventually enters a low point for the characters, a certain momentum fails to sustain the excitement for the audience. Nevertheless, the ending, where the true culprit is found, and the subsequent long shot of Cheng Bing walking on the street, is a beautifully designed and impactful scene that surpasses mere preaching and salutes.
Read Moreˇ
LiuInteresting1 year ago rating:9
Watched the 5:20 PM screening on December 24th and was moved several times throughout. It's a pretty good film, I'd give it a 7.8 out of 10. There's no need to praise Zhang Yi's acting skills again; overall, it's solid. I hope the world can occasionally be a little fair to all the good people and forever punish the bad ones. The world needs a Cheng Bing, but I can't become Cheng Bing... Meanwhile, I'm also watching a TV drama, and currently, I feel like it's not that good anymore.
Win1 year ago rating:9.9
Finally, I've seen a good realistic drama that, although some plot points may seem a bit contrived, the flaws don't overshadow its brilliance. The scene where they eat barbecue, drink beer, and suddenly start singing together, or when Binzi shouts "Happy New Year" in the snowy field—these details are inexplicably surreal yet incredibly authentic, a nameless release of emotions. And the final scene where Zhang Yi has convulsions in prison, a culmination of suppressed outbursts. Also, the camera zooming out from the pedestrian crossing, gradually transitioning from silence to the restoration of various noises in reality—it's as if everything has finally returned to normal.
Read Moreˇ
SoyBoom1 year ago rating:8.6
7/10; Quite touching, and the pace is indeed fast. The actors are also quite convincing. However, some parts of the film were shot quite roughly, but many scenes that express emotions have a lot of substance... I can only say that the director understands men.
PancakeEscape1 year ago rating:6.9
The early part of the drama was quite tight, but the middle and later parts were particularly boring. It felt a bit like how I used to start my English essays with impressive sentences and then desperately fill in the rest for the word count. However, it was quite surprising to find out later that the master let go because he couldn't catch up. Other than that, it was neither outstanding nor disappointing. Wei Chen's acting was awkward to the point of being refreshing. The scene where the middle-aged man sings while drunk was truly inspired by life, but my goodness, it felt so forced that it became a bit funny.
Read Moreˇ
FanFanGoGoGo1 year ago rating:8.9
Based on a true story, the script is solid and touching, and the actors deliver excellent performances. The details like the text message of wanting to give up sent to an unknown recipient, the illusion of hearing a farewell at the train station, and the moments of looking back really moved me. I particularly liked the handling of the ending, where after many years, Cheng and his team complete their mission and then lose their direction amidst the vast sea of people. It adds a tragic tone to the sorrowful heroism.
Matcha Skin Li Xiugen1 year ago rating:7
There are too many melodramatic scenes, and it's the most realistic that the five of them won't all make it to the end. I won't be Cheng Bing, but I admire him. Can Zhang Yi break out of this comfort zone? It feels like it's always these same few people in every movie, and it's starting to feel repetitive and predictable.
MeowHatless1 year ago rating:9.7
I cried my heart out. After watching the movie, there were even people applauding in the theater. It's a pretty good film, with incredibly powerful emotional manipulation. After finishing it, I searched everywhere for the story behind it, hoping for a more satisfying resolution. Unfortunately, apart from that documentary story, I couldn't find any related news articles.
Kilo1 year ago rating:9.7
Zhang Yi really knows how to choose scripts and act. Everyone has praised him enough, so I'll mention a plot that left a deep impression on me: Old Zhang said that young police officers all want to crack big cases, but they never think about the countless shattered families and altered life trajectories behind each big case. When Cai Bin discovered he had stomach cancer and was competing in a swimming match with Cheng Bing, he shouted halfway through, exhausted, "Have you ever thought that if we haven't found him yet, maybe it's because God has given him a chance to start over? " Honestly, when I saw this scene, my anger and helplessness were indescribable. But in Liu Huan's end credits song, I found the answer: "Good people don't necessarily receive good rewards, so why should bad people enjoy peace and happiness? " "I am the karma you created through killing, and I am also the cause of your rebirth!" Please make sure to listen to the entire end credits song before leaving.
After watching it, my mom asked, "Is it worth spending a lifetime clinging to one thing?" It reminded me of the ending of "Sealed for Thirteen Years," where the victims and the police officers bowed and saluted each other. I said to her, "Think about the victim's father who handed out tea eggs. Do you think this kind of courage and determination is worth it?" Thirty-six years ago, Liu Huan sang, "The golden shield, forged with hot blood," and thirty-six years later, he sang, "I want the ghosts with remorse in their eyes to see justice.
Read Moreˇ
Dith1 year ago rating:9
For twenty years, the pursuit of the culprit wasn't the central theme. Instead, the story highlighted the changes in the lives of the three brothers and their persistence after experiencing life-changing events (the brothers) and Cheng Bing. Each character had a relatively complete story and interpersonal relationships, making the entire story more cohesive. Lastly, using the group photo of the three brothers as the ending was the perfect touch, combining it with the recurring thread of the photographs throughout the film. It felt as if we were transported back to 2002, to the complete, just, and highly capable Three Brothers.
Read Moreˇ
Lily1 year ago rating:8.5
This movie made me feel really uncomfortable. One thing that particularly struck a chord with me was when Cheng Bing was feeling disheartened and considering giving up, but then he heard his master's wife reveal the truth that Master's death had nothing to do with Wang Er Yong. It turned out that one of the main catalysts for everything that happened didn't even exist in the end. The ten years of dedicated effort, everyone from the Three Squads suffered so much.
Chilly1 year ago rating:5.5
The story is a good one, but if it's not told well, I suggest not making it. Without the struggle between procedural justice and moral justice, the actions of the Three Musketeers lose their tragic meaning. Instead, the pacing throughout the entire film feels deliberately dragging, trying to manipulate emotions, and by the end, even sympathy is worn away. In the earlier scenes, Zhang Yi strutting around with a briefcase is reminiscent of a coal magnate, and it's no surprise that he once again showcases his acting prowess.
Yinggu1 year ago rating:5.5
The narrative expression, character development, plot progression, and actor performances were all relatively mediocre. Watching several men drinking together made me feel extremely awkward. The constant shifting of locations (with massive white artistic lettering) only gave the impression of being contrived, repetitive, lazy, and gimmicky. After finishing it, I couldn't help but ask my friend, "Was this just a promotional film?
Tadashi1 year ago rating:5.5
Did you cry? Were you touched? Moved? Sighed? No? Then let me sprinkle some manly vows and steadfastness.
Still haven't shed a tear? Then here's some bitterness and desolation of manhood. It wouldn't be appropriate if you're not moved by now, huh?
It's unexpectedly ugly and torturous. In the stinking and overly long two hours, the only pleasant surprise was Cao Bingkun, who portrayed the appropriately sleazy character of the Buddhist bead man. Greasiness is not a gender-specific issue; it entirely depends on the individual.
I truly can't believe they managed to turn a human story from the depths of the Deep Blue's pen into this mess. Such a great story and foundation, forcefully transformed into a pile of overnight defense. It's no wonder, Chen Sicheng, even as a producer, you managed to saturate the entire film with that excess of ego and greasiness. When I walked out of the theater, I felt as if my hair had been tainted by the stench.
Read Moreˇ
ShadowDust1 year ago rating:6.6
3.5/ Zhang Yi's acting is beyond words, truly deserving of high praise. The foundation of authenticity prevents the movie's story itself from being poorly told. The portrayal of the suspenseful atmosphere and the impact of wasted time are both extremely well-executed. It's a pity, though, that I couldn't be convinced even in the slightest by the portrayal of the bonds among the members of the Third Squad in the film. Arguments rely solely on shouting, and the poor sound quality even brings a terrible viewing experience. The transition from Shenyang to Guangdong is brushed over in a single stroke, and the pursuit process is barely mentioned in the later scenes in Xishuangbanna. However, when Zhang Yi sends a message saying he can't hold on anymore, not knowing whom he sent it to, and the heartfelt farewells between the teammates at the end, it's truly tear-jerking. It turned out to be an unexpected masterpiece.
Read Moreˇ
Jane1 year ago rating:8.1
Inspired by "Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri," but turned into an overly dramatic and contrived crime series on CCTV-8. Despite going through numerous difficulties, the case is ultimately solved, but it feels forced and artificial. The cinematography relies heavily on long, sentimental shots, which adds to the contrived nature. Knowing that people are going to leave but still desperately trying to keep them and acting pitifully, it's the third level of contrivance. While "Three Billboards" portrayed life, this one feels like a cliché inspirational story.
Read Moreˇ
El Duderino1 year ago rating:8.9
The quality is top-notch, it's a meticulously crafted production. The storyline and pacing are good. The actors are all impressive (except for Li Chen).
There are also some drawbacks, like the director adding unnecessary suspense; the sudden disappearance of Cai Bin and Xu Yizhou's characters; and the forced sense of tragedy created in the glass room at the end.
This director gives me the impression of being talented and visionary, but lacking finesse. I'm really looking forward to seeing their future works after further refinement and integration of their skills.
Sleepy1 year ago rating:9.7
It's a story about a suspected case of using torture to extract a confession, resulting in the death of the suspect. This leads to the entire team of "Three Teams" being imprisoned. After their release, they work together to track down the killer, but gradually some members drop out until the team leader successfully captures the culprit. The plot is logically structured, the storyline is reasonable, the acting is outstanding, and the pacing keeps you on the edge of your seat. It evokes both laughter and tears—a perfect masterpiece!
Caiya Skywalker1 year ago rating:7.8
Whether it was well-directed or well-acted, upon closer examination, it was none other than the producer, Chen Sicheng. Case solved! Finally figured out where this overwhelming scent of old masculinity on the screen came from, and why women always seem to be relegated to decorative roles and stumbling blocks! PS: "It's not uniforms that the people trust, but the system" is truly one of the most humorous lines I've heard in the cinema this year.
Fiery Spirit1 year ago rating:6.6
It's a detective drama film, with no suspense. It became a bit predictable when the teacher's wife said at the end that his master stopped pursuing because he had grown old. I even wondered if there would be a plot twist, but the abrupt ending was intriguing. The storyline flows smoothly, indicating that the original script is quite good. I appreciate the skillful handling of emotional elements, which doesn't feel forced. It's an enjoyable watch.
MarquisWill1 year ago rating:9.6
Good people don't always achieve good results. How can one become enlightened just by letting go? Even after traversing rivers and mountains, the wicked still need stubborn people to grind against.
Tender grass fears frost, and frost fears the sun. The act of killing lives will be repaid. The blue sky follows the righteous path and adheres to proper principles, sending you on your way to transcendence to cultivate karma!
Hold on? Move! Break!
RockDog1 year ago rating:6.6
The biggest realization while watching is that some paths ultimately have to be walked alone. It's truly admirable how the real-life counterpart of the character has persevered all these years. The movie adds some dramatic conflicts for the sake of plot twists, but real life can be either more mundane or more tumultuous, making it difficult to judge. Some people's performances in a few scenes were quite out of place...
2323231 year ago rating:8.9
A very multifaceted story, thanks to the interpretations of all the actors! There were many conflicts that could have been portrayed better through visual storytelling. It lacked a bit in that aspect, such as the scene where Wang Da Yong gets beaten. It's such an important, helpless, brutal, relatable, and yet unwilling-to-accept moment, but it missed the mark in conveying its intended meaning.
Little Pineapple1 year ago rating:9
A sigh. When everything settles, justice eventually arrives, obsessions turn into truth, but time rushes by, leaving behind a bustling crowd as if no one cares about the changes that have occurred. For what purpose, is it truly worth it? Only a clear conscience can provide an answer. I watched this story on the winter solstice, and I suppose the daylight will continue to lengthen from now on.
Nidao Auntie1 year ago rating:8.5
The order in which the remaining four members of the Third Squad leave was predicted by me in advance. It can't be helped; I just understand the ways of the world too well. The emperor's performance was decent (not in a derogatory sense), with the content and style of his acting remaining within his comfort zone and sphere of control. Overall, it's watchable but lacks surprises.
Fanny841 year ago rating:9.2
I'm deeply moved by the captain's life, touched by his perseverance, and saddened by his fate. At first, it felt like I was watching a thrilling race, but the film had a strong impact, so much so that my husband and I also watched the drama adaptation. Lao Zhang (Old Zhang) remains the same Lao Zhang, and even the youthful aspirations are portrayed without a hint of worry.
BitterMelon1 year ago rating:9.1
3.5 stars. It's a great story, but I still felt a bit uncomfortable while watching, perhaps because our perspectives are opposite. However, regardless of our choices, there is no right or wrong, we just keep moving forward. The beginning of the story is propelled, while the ending is drawn out. When Wang Eryong gets captured, Zhang Yi's performance is truly touching.
EastBlue1 year ago rating:8.5
The overall plot was quite satisfying and enjoyable. The pacing and storytelling were well executed. Zhang's acting skills remain solid, and he delivered a compelling performance.
What stood out to me was the teacher who played the role of Xiufo. The genuine brotherhood portrayed in the drama really touched me. Zhang's attention to detail in his acting is remarkable!
Ten1 year ago rating:7.8
I went to the cinema after seeing the positive reviews, even for the midnight screening. The result was average. Former colleagues of the Great Squad gradually left, and the storytelling felt like a laundry list. The final confrontation between Zhang Yi and the culprit was baffling. What benefit does this action have for solving the case, other than alerting the suspect?
RhythmMaster1 year ago rating:9.5
The pacing is excellent, with no dull moments throughout. The segment in the cemetery is both passionate and touching, but reality is cruel. As people gradually diminish, everyone begins their new lives and feels a sense of desolation. Fortunately, hard work pays off, and I hope Cheng and the team can embrace their new lives. Your daughter is still waiting for you.
Zhang Yi's acting is excellent. I particularly liked a scene at the end. Finally, he can say goodbye to the past and start a new life. While watching the movie, I always hoped that Bingge could move forward.
Fortunately, the director portrayed it, otherwise it would have been really heart-wrenching~
Looking back at the domestic films I've seen this year, this one should easily rank among the top three. The plot is tightly woven, and the lead actor's performance goes without saying.
What impressed me the most throughout the entire film were the cinematography and the music. It's evident that the director put a lot of effort into them. Zhang Yi is truly perfect for this role; it feels like he's the same kind of person in real life.
China has finally been able to produce this kind of suspenseful film, and it's something that we can all be proud of.
I've watched Zhang Yi play a police officer so many times, but I never get tired of it. Instead, it's easy for me to be drawn into the movie. If I like this film, I will also enjoy Liu Huan's ending song. "Ren Jian Dao" depicts Cheng Bing's entire life: "I want to live this life to see the snow orchids.
I want to wear out these shoes, barefoot in the windswept desert. I want to witness the clouds and rainbows in the broad sky, and hold a torch at night. I want everything in this vast universe to have its laws. I want those who leave home, no matter how late, to return.
I want the rain that falls from the sky to return to the sky. I want to eat this mouthful of rice and guard this wild land. I want all the paths in this world to exist under the blue sky. For a breath, for a principle, for a sacrifice, I will carry on till the end." Cheng Bing truly carries on till the end.
There's a scene where Cheng Bing swims across the river to the other side. Cai Bin shouts behind him, urging him to let go. Before this scene, Cai Bin always mentioned the "attachment" in Buddhism. This scene is absolutely amazing. Cheng Bing alone swims to the other side of the river, and he also persists to the end on his own.
It's both an attachment and a crossing. I think I will watch the drama version, although I'm a bit scared...
The movie was so disappointing. It's far worse than the TV drama that I'm currently following, which has been touching and made me shed tears uncontrollably. I came to watch the movie with high hopes, but it didn't feel like a movie at all.
It was more like a narrative-less PowerPoint presentation. Every plot twist felt forced, without any buildup or logical coherence. Sitting through over two hours of it was agonizing, and it didn't move me at all. I just wanted it to end quickly so I could move on.
I don't understand who those people giving it positive reviews are.
The drama made me sob uncontrollably. It's undoubtedly the best drama of 2023, despite some plot holes that can be overlooked. I deduct one star because of Li Chen's performance (originally wanted to give the movie one star just because of him, but the movie is actually quite good, so it doesn't deserve such low rating).
Adding to that, the plot that I couldn't stand the most is Zhang Yi's family's sudden emotional coldness. Before the incident, it seemed like they wanted to have a third child, but after the incident, it feels like he's the one who killed his wife, lover, and daughter.
It's incredibly unsettling.
Is this a new genre of film? A TV drama-style movie? The whole thing feels like a messy mishmash of scenes, and there's always some inexplicable burden that keeps shaking. It lacks rhythm and cinematic quality.
I'm sorry, I didn't pay enough attention to the poster, and I completely regret watching it. Chen Sicheng and anyone associated with this project should be avoided in the future.
Well, how should I put it? It's a tragic story. However, the middle part is quite lengthy, and I got tired of seeing them chase all over the country. The sudden change in attitude of the few remaining people at Old Zhang's grave felt too abrupt and not as touching as expected.
Zhang Yi's performance feels somewhat formulaic, and his constant gloomy expression throughout the film made it a bit boring to watch.
It seems like Cheng's character is destined for misfortune... Not a single storyline was well executed, and the creators should apologize to the families of the victims. Cheng's character was portrayed by Zhang Yi without any charm. He started off strong, but later on, he should have been more burdened and complex, expressing regret, guilt, and a sense of depth.
Almost all the characters were superficially developed and lacked depth. The details were scarce. The editing was poor, and the pacing was off. The balance between elaboration and conciseness was not well-handled. It had a strong masculine vibe, and there were no female characters, none at all.
At the end of the year, another member joins the list of the top 10 annual domestic releases! This year, there have been many films with a realistic theme, but only "Triple Squad" has delivered a satisfying answer under strict censorship.
Despite the use of many effective but clichéd plot elements, the film maintains a smooth pace with its straightforward narrative. It evokes laughter and tears, accompanied by the clues of "chasing the murderer," presenting a comprehensive portrayal of the police officers' dedication to justice.
The chef's glance back at the train station ticket gate, the insurance seller's shout amidst the New Year fireworks, and Binzi's cry by the riverbank all depict the struggle for life and ideals.
Cheng Bing, who has nothing to lose and nothing to worry about, persists until the end with the belief of the "Triple Squad," leaving behind a lonely yet immensely heroic figure that dissipates into the vast sea of people.
I watched this film on a whim, and it started off really well. The cinematography had a nice touch from the very beginning, and it had a gradually building filmic quality.
The middle part was fairly tight, but the tension seemed slightly lacking towards the end. And when I saw the faces of the actors playing the Second Brave, I couldn't help but feel a bit strained...
(Never expected that!)
The most unexpectedly imaginative episode - Flipping the Door.
A few years ago, I watched the first part of "Deep Blue Story," but I can't quite remember the original plot. I recall that there were no teammates in the impression. The film's addition of teammates joining and leaving, as well as the master acknowledging his own inability to keep up, is a great adaptation.
It adds some interesting plot elements, creates a thrilling and fluctuating pace, and emphasizes Brother Bing's unwavering determination.
The beginning of the film had a feeling similar to a typical detective movie, giving me a sense that it would be very popcorn-worthy.
Then, the combination of violin and a big title immediately changed that atmosphere and made it more intriguing. The segment from imprisonment to tomb sweeping temporarily lost the direction of the story, but it necessary to show everyone's changes.
The teammates' retirement and the soulful greeting in the ending created a desolate atmosphere.
The conversation with the bureau chief seemed to subtly satirize certain things. The indoor set design was very well done, resembling an ordinary person's home.
The music was stunning! The violin near the music sheet and the lightly distorted electric guitar were used to enhance the tense and ethereal atmosphere, and it was very concise and effective.
The only minor drawback was that the font used when switching cities felt a bit "unrefined" or out of place.
There were several climactic moments in the drama that didn't rely on background music to create impact, showcasing the actors' superb and moving performances. For example, the scene where the male lead, just released from prison, is given tea eggs by his family.
Another example is the segment where the team members awaken in the cemetery and go together to apprehend Wang Eryong, which was accompanied by a simple guitar melody to evoke emotions.
The pursuit of justice as an ordinary person is incredibly long and arduous. In the end, it's all about human matters—being washed by fate and experiencing the brilliance of life. Holding onto one's convictions is not a derogatory term; it means doing what one believes is right and unraveling the knots in one's heart is a lifelong lesson.
The tragedy and glimmer of ordinary people serve as a constant reminder.
The final thought of the film is, after spending most of one's life in pursuit of a goal, how should the days ahead be lived? Cheng Bing has stayed in the past, but the gears of time don't wait for anyone, and Li Chen's portrayal of Yang Shutao becoming the director is the perfect contrast.
The story is a good one. As soon as I left the cinema, I said to myself, "If this were a novel, it would definitely be very enjoyable to read." Unfortunately, the director failed to showcase the brilliance of the story.
The portrayal of the characters felt too artificial and forced, lacking authenticity and naturalness.
It's a good story, and the director's filming techniques are quite impressive. There's a lot of restraint in many aspects. Moreover, the writer starting from the perspective of the male lead is excellent.
The years-long pursuit of the culprit, the feelings of resentment, sadness, and injustice are what touch us, the audience, and make us admire those who can persevere. From the first supporter to the first one to leave, to several people leaving due to various real-life issues, we can understand them, but it still feels very painful.
It also reminds me of the earlier work, with Zhang Yi playing the lead role. It's quite ridiculous how the starting perspective is the protagonist on the surface, but actually highlights the difficulty of portraying the antagonist, their deep emotions and sense of loyalty.
They deliberately imitate the image of a big brother from Hong Kong films, overlooking the genuine need to tell the story of the righteous side and their internal struggles. The contrast between these two works is significant.
Lao Ma leaving signifies Cheng Bing letting go of his attachment to his wife. Lao Liao leaving signifies Cheng Bing letting go of his longing for his child. Xiao Xu leaving signifies Cheng Bing letting go of a stable life. Bin Zi leaving signifies Cheng Bing letting go of the possibility of redemption.
However, leaving does not necessarily mean giving up. Everyone has their own choices. Never ridicule those who are braver and more resilient than oneself.
The dark shadow at the alley entrance represents the obsession I chased after, the group photo at the celebration embodies the curse I endured, the graffiti behind the mirror symbolizes the life I gambled on, and the shoe covers at the doorstep signify the fate I exchanged.
Neglecting to install burglar-proof windows, my identity was stolen by wicked thieves. Neglecting to purchase life insurance, I played hide-and-seek with destiny. Changing from a uniform to a prisoner's outfit, justice has been frozen in the freezer of the judiciary.
The police anthem has turned into prison regulations, and the killer has been reveling in the blocks of a game, evading capture. People come and go, each with their own shore to swim towards.
Several police officers went from being full of spirit to being down and out, and it really saddened me from the bottom of my heart. ???? By the end, it felt like Wang Eryong truly had the chance to start anew, just as Lao Liao said: a happy and harmonious family, and he even managed to make himself look respectable despite his past wrongdoings...
But why does he get to start over? Can Cheng Bing start over and return to the way things were? Can the other members of the Three Teams, who had promising futures, start over and go back to the past? Everyone can start over, except for Wang Eryong!
I'm already tired of seeing Zhang Yi in these kinds of roles, but I couldn't resist watching because of Wei Chen's face. How can someone look so handsome with that hairstyle?
It's like he was born to be an actor. Oh my goodness!
It's just average, I would recommend it if you simply enjoy watching crime dramas, but I think you might be a bit disappointed with this one.
Overall, it feels like it's only focusing on the main character's journey, and the other characters are just carried by the actors' performances.
There seems to be a lot of attention to detail in the design, but it comes across as too straightforward and a bit dry.
It's hard to evaluate. I give up, Wei Chen is really handsome, I can't believe it.
The pre-internet era of criminal investigations has become the focus of domestic crime film creators. Due to the lack of technological means like surveillance, the process of solving cases is filled with twists and turns.
"The Third Squad" achieves a remarkably high level of completion. By employing a more realistic approach and toning down the suspenseful atmosphere, the drama captivates viewers with solid storytelling and compelling performances.
Ensembles are the most challenging to write and portray, and although the film mainly focuses on Cheng Bing, portrayed by Zhang Yi, the other characters in "The Third Squad" are equally outstanding.
Whether it's the performances of Zhang Zixian, Wang Xiao, Wei Chen, or the detailed characterization of their roles, everything feels authentic and emotionally moving. However, as the story eventually enters a low point for the characters, a certain momentum fails to sustain the excitement for the audience.
Nevertheless, the ending, where the true culprit is found, and the subsequent long shot of Cheng Bing walking on the street, is a beautifully designed and impactful scene that surpasses mere preaching and salutes.
Watched the 5:20 PM screening on December 24th and was moved several times throughout. It's a pretty good film, I'd give it a 7.8 out of 10. There's no need to praise Zhang Yi's acting skills again; overall, it's solid.
I hope the world can occasionally be a little fair to all the good people and forever punish the bad ones. The world needs a Cheng Bing, but I can't become Cheng Bing...
Meanwhile, I'm also watching a TV drama, and currently, I feel like it's not that good anymore.
Finally, I've seen a good realistic drama that, although some plot points may seem a bit contrived, the flaws don't overshadow its brilliance. The scene where they eat barbecue, drink beer, and suddenly start singing together, or when Binzi shouts "Happy New Year" in the snowy field—these details are inexplicably surreal yet incredibly authentic, a nameless release of emotions.
And the final scene where Zhang Yi has convulsions in prison, a culmination of suppressed outbursts. Also, the camera zooming out from the pedestrian crossing, gradually transitioning from silence to the restoration of various noises in reality—it's as if everything has finally returned to normal.
7/10; Quite touching, and the pace is indeed fast. The actors are also quite convincing. However, some parts of the film were shot quite roughly, but many scenes that express emotions have a lot of substance...
I can only say that the director understands men.
The early part of the drama was quite tight, but the middle and later parts were particularly boring. It felt a bit like how I used to start my English essays with impressive sentences and then desperately fill in the rest for the word count.
However, it was quite surprising to find out later that the master let go because he couldn't catch up. Other than that, it was neither outstanding nor disappointing. Wei Chen's acting was awkward to the point of being refreshing.
The scene where the middle-aged man sings while drunk was truly inspired by life, but my goodness, it felt so forced that it became a bit funny.
Based on a true story, the script is solid and touching, and the actors deliver excellent performances. The details like the text message of wanting to give up sent to an unknown recipient, the illusion of hearing a farewell at the train station, and the moments of looking back really moved me.
I particularly liked the handling of the ending, where after many years, Cheng and his team complete their mission and then lose their direction amidst the vast sea of people.
It adds a tragic tone to the sorrowful heroism.
There are too many melodramatic scenes, and it's the most realistic that the five of them won't all make it to the end. I won't be Cheng Bing, but I admire him. Can Zhang Yi break out of this comfort zone?
It feels like it's always these same few people in every movie, and it's starting to feel repetitive and predictable.
I cried my heart out. After watching the movie, there were even people applauding in the theater. It's a pretty good film, with incredibly powerful emotional manipulation. After finishing it, I searched everywhere for the story behind it, hoping for a more satisfying resolution.
Unfortunately, apart from that documentary story, I couldn't find any related news articles.
Zhang Yi really knows how to choose scripts and act. Everyone has praised him enough, so I'll mention a plot that left a deep impression on me: Old Zhang said that young police officers all want to crack big cases, but they never think about the countless shattered families and altered life trajectories behind each big case.
When Cai Bin discovered he had stomach cancer and was competing in a swimming match with Cheng Bing, he shouted halfway through, exhausted, "Have you ever thought that if we haven't found him yet, maybe it's because God has given him a chance to start over?
" Honestly, when I saw this scene, my anger and helplessness were indescribable. But in Liu Huan's end credits song, I found the answer: "Good people don't necessarily receive good rewards, so why should bad people enjoy peace and happiness?
" "I am the karma you created through killing, and I am also the cause of your rebirth!" Please make sure to listen to the entire end credits song before leaving.
After watching it, my mom asked, "Is it worth spending a lifetime clinging to one thing?" It reminded me of the ending of "Sealed for Thirteen Years," where the victims and the police officers bowed and saluted each other.
I said to her, "Think about the victim's father who handed out tea eggs. Do you think this kind of courage and determination is worth it?" Thirty-six years ago, Liu Huan sang, "The golden shield, forged with hot blood," and thirty-six years later, he sang, "I want the ghosts with remorse in their eyes to see justice.
For twenty years, the pursuit of the culprit wasn't the central theme. Instead, the story highlighted the changes in the lives of the three brothers and their persistence after experiencing life-changing events (the brothers) and Cheng Bing. Each character had a relatively complete story and interpersonal relationships, making the entire story more cohesive.
Lastly, using the group photo of the three brothers as the ending was the perfect touch, combining it with the recurring thread of the photographs throughout the film. It felt as if we were transported back to 2002, to the complete, just, and highly capable Three Brothers.
This movie made me feel really uncomfortable. One thing that particularly struck a chord with me was when Cheng Bing was feeling disheartened and considering giving up, but then he heard his master's wife reveal the truth that Master's death had nothing to do with Wang Er Yong.
It turned out that one of the main catalysts for everything that happened didn't even exist in the end. The ten years of dedicated effort, everyone from the Three Squads suffered so much.
The story is a good one, but if it's not told well, I suggest not making it. Without the struggle between procedural justice and moral justice, the actions of the Three Musketeers lose their tragic meaning.
Instead, the pacing throughout the entire film feels deliberately dragging, trying to manipulate emotions, and by the end, even sympathy is worn away. In the earlier scenes, Zhang Yi strutting around with a briefcase is reminiscent of a coal magnate, and it's no surprise that he once again showcases his acting prowess.
The narrative expression, character development, plot progression, and actor performances were all relatively mediocre. Watching several men drinking together made me feel extremely awkward.
The constant shifting of locations (with massive white artistic lettering) only gave the impression of being contrived, repetitive, lazy, and gimmicky. After finishing it, I couldn't help but ask my friend, "Was this just a promotional film?
Did you cry? Were you touched? Moved? Sighed? No? Then let me sprinkle some manly vows and steadfastness.
Still haven't shed a tear? Then here's some bitterness and desolation of manhood.
It wouldn't be appropriate if you're not moved by now, huh?
It's unexpectedly ugly and torturous. In the stinking and overly long two hours, the only pleasant surprise was Cao Bingkun, who portrayed the appropriately sleazy character of the Buddhist bead man.
Greasiness is not a gender-specific issue; it entirely depends on the individual.
I truly can't believe they managed to turn a human story from the depths of the Deep Blue's pen into this mess.
Such a great story and foundation, forcefully transformed into a pile of overnight defense. It's no wonder, Chen Sicheng, even as a producer, you managed to saturate the entire film with that excess of ego and greasiness.
When I walked out of the theater, I felt as if my hair had been tainted by the stench.
3.5/ Zhang Yi's acting is beyond words, truly deserving of high praise. The foundation of authenticity prevents the movie's story itself from being poorly told. The portrayal of the suspenseful atmosphere and the impact of wasted time are both extremely well-executed.
It's a pity, though, that I couldn't be convinced even in the slightest by the portrayal of the bonds among the members of the Third Squad in the film. Arguments rely solely on shouting, and the poor sound quality even brings a terrible viewing experience.
The transition from Shenyang to Guangdong is brushed over in a single stroke, and the pursuit process is barely mentioned in the later scenes in Xishuangbanna. However, when Zhang Yi sends a message saying he can't hold on anymore, not knowing whom he sent it to, and the heartfelt farewells between the teammates at the end, it's truly tear-jerking.
It turned out to be an unexpected masterpiece.
Inspired by "Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri," but turned into an overly dramatic and contrived crime series on CCTV-8. Despite going through numerous difficulties, the case is ultimately solved, but it feels forced and artificial.
The cinematography relies heavily on long, sentimental shots, which adds to the contrived nature. Knowing that people are going to leave but still desperately trying to keep them and acting pitifully, it's the third level of contrivance.
While "Three Billboards" portrayed life, this one feels like a cliché inspirational story.
The quality is top-notch, it's a meticulously crafted production. The storyline and pacing are good. The actors are all impressive (except for Li Chen).
There are also some drawbacks, like the director adding unnecessary suspense; the sudden disappearance of Cai Bin and Xu Yizhou's characters; and the forced sense of tragedy created in the glass room at the end.
This director gives me the impression of being talented and visionary, but lacking finesse. I'm really looking forward to seeing their future works after further refinement and integration of their skills.
It's a story about a suspected case of using torture to extract a confession, resulting in the death of the suspect. This leads to the entire team of "Three Teams" being imprisoned. After their release, they work together to track down the killer, but gradually some members drop out until the team leader successfully captures the culprit.
The plot is logically structured, the storyline is reasonable, the acting is outstanding, and the pacing keeps you on the edge of your seat. It evokes both laughter and tears—a perfect masterpiece!
Whether it was well-directed or well-acted, upon closer examination, it was none other than the producer, Chen Sicheng. Case solved! Finally figured out where this overwhelming scent of old masculinity on the screen came from, and why women always seem to be relegated to decorative roles and stumbling blocks!
PS: "It's not uniforms that the people trust, but the system" is truly one of the most humorous lines I've heard in the cinema this year.
It's a detective drama film, with no suspense. It became a bit predictable when the teacher's wife said at the end that his master stopped pursuing because he had grown old. I even wondered if there would be a plot twist, but the abrupt ending was intriguing.
The storyline flows smoothly, indicating that the original script is quite good. I appreciate the skillful handling of emotional elements, which doesn't feel forced. It's an enjoyable watch.
Good people don't always achieve good results. How can one become enlightened just by letting go? Even after traversing rivers and mountains, the wicked still need stubborn people to grind against.
Tender grass fears frost, and frost fears the sun. The act of killing lives will be repaid. The blue sky follows the righteous path and adheres to proper principles, sending you on your way to transcendence to cultivate karma!
Hold on? Move! Break!
The biggest realization while watching is that some paths ultimately have to be walked alone. It's truly admirable how the real-life counterpart of the character has persevered all these years. The movie adds some dramatic conflicts for the sake of plot twists, but real life can be either more mundane or more tumultuous, making it difficult to judge.
Some people's performances in a few scenes were quite out of place...
A very multifaceted story, thanks to the interpretations of all the actors! There were many conflicts that could have been portrayed better through visual storytelling. It lacked a bit in that aspect, such as the scene where Wang Da Yong gets beaten.
It's such an important, helpless, brutal, relatable, and yet unwilling-to-accept moment, but it missed the mark in conveying its intended meaning.
A sigh. When everything settles, justice eventually arrives, obsessions turn into truth, but time rushes by, leaving behind a bustling crowd as if no one cares about the changes that have occurred. For what purpose, is it truly worth it?
Only a clear conscience can provide an answer. I watched this story on the winter solstice, and I suppose the daylight will continue to lengthen from now on.
The order in which the remaining four members of the Third Squad leave was predicted by me in advance. It can't be helped; I just understand the ways of the world too well. The emperor's performance was decent (not in a derogatory sense), with the content and style of his acting remaining within his comfort zone and sphere of control.
Overall, it's watchable but lacks surprises.
I'm deeply moved by the captain's life, touched by his perseverance, and saddened by his fate. At first, it felt like I was watching a thrilling race, but the film had a strong impact, so much so that my husband and I also watched the drama adaptation.
Lao Zhang (Old Zhang) remains the same Lao Zhang, and even the youthful aspirations are portrayed without a hint of worry.
3.5 stars. It's a great story, but I still felt a bit uncomfortable while watching, perhaps because our perspectives are opposite. However, regardless of our choices, there is no right or wrong, we just keep moving forward.
The beginning of the story is propelled, while the ending is drawn out. When Wang Eryong gets captured, Zhang Yi's performance is truly touching.
The overall plot was quite satisfying and enjoyable. The pacing and storytelling were well executed. Zhang's acting skills remain solid, and he delivered a compelling performance.
What stood out to me was the teacher who played the role of Xiufo.
The genuine brotherhood portrayed in the drama really touched me. Zhang's attention to detail in his acting is remarkable!
I went to the cinema after seeing the positive reviews, even for the midnight screening. The result was average. Former colleagues of the Great Squad gradually left, and the storytelling felt like a laundry list. The final confrontation between Zhang Yi and the culprit was baffling.
What benefit does this action have for solving the case, other than alerting the suspect?
The pacing is excellent, with no dull moments throughout. The segment in the cemetery is both passionate and touching, but reality is cruel. As people gradually diminish, everyone begins their new lives and feels a sense of desolation.
Fortunately, hard work pays off, and I hope Cheng and the team can embrace their new lives. Your daughter is still waiting for you.